The Playful World of Canines: Unlocking the Mystery of Why Dogs Shake Their Toys

by | Behavior

New Dog Tips is reader-supported. Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a small commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase a product or take an action via these links.

If you’ve ever owned a dog, you’ve likely witnessed the familiar sight of your furry friend vigorously shaking their toy from side to side. It’s a universal behavior that transcends breeds, age, and size – from tiny Chihuahuas to massive Great Danes, all dogs seem to enjoy engaging in this playful activity. But what’s behind this fascinating display? Why do dogs shake their toys, and what can we learn from this seemingly instinctual behavior?

Unraveling the mystery of why dogs shake their toys not only provides us with an insight into the playful world of canines, but it also helps us to better understand and connect with our beloved pets. By delving into the reasons behind this behavior, we can enhance the bond between humans and dogs, create more engaging playtime experiences, and improve our dogs’ overall well-being.

Historical Context of Canine Behavior

Domestication of Dogs

The domestication of dogs dates back thousands of years, with some estimates suggesting that humans and canines began forming their unique bond as early as 40,000 years ago. Over time, dogs have been bred and selected for various purposes, such as hunting, herding, and companionship. Through this long and complex history, dogs have evolved to be highly attuned to human emotions, gestures, and behaviors, making them an integral part of our lives.

Evolutionary Traits in Play

As descendants of wolves, dogs have retained some of their ancestors’ traits and behaviors. One such example is the act of shaking toys, which can be traced back to their predatory instincts. In the wild, wolves would shake their prey from side to side in order to immobilize or kill it. Over time, as dogs became domesticated and their roles shifted, these predatory behaviors evolved into more playful activities.

When dogs engage in play, they often mimic hunting, fighting, and other survival-related behaviors. Shaking toys is just one manifestation of these deeply ingrained instincts. Playtime serves as an essential means for dogs to practice and refine their motor skills, socialize with other dogs or humans, and release pent-up energy. By better understanding the evolutionary roots of our dogs’ behaviors, we can appreciate their unique quirks and provide them with the most enriching experiences possible.

Instinctual Explanations

Prey Instinct

Simulating Hunting Behavior

One of the primary reasons dogs shake their toys is to simulate hunting behavior. In the wild, their ancestors would stalk, chase, and capture prey to survive. Although domesticated dogs no longer rely on hunting for sustenance, the instincts remain deeply ingrained in their DNA. Shaking toys allows dogs to act out these predatory behaviors in a safe and controlled manner, providing both mental and physical stimulation.

Subduing and Killing Prey

In addition to simulating hunting behavior, the act of shaking toys also taps into the instinct to subdue and kill prey. When a dog shakes a toy, they are mimicking the motion used to snap the neck of their prey, effectively killing it. This action not only satisfies their primal instincts but also provides an outlet for their natural urges in a non-destructive way.

Pack Behavior

Establishing Hierarchy

Dogs are social animals, and in the wild, they would live in packs with a complex hierarchical structure. Shaking toys can serve as a way for dogs to assert their dominance within the pack or establish their place in the hierarchy. By demonstrating their strength and skill in play, dogs can communicate their status to other dogs or their human caregivers.

Social Bonding

Pack behavior is also essential for social bonding between dogs and their human family members. Playtime, including shaking toys, allows dogs to engage in social interactions that help to strengthen the bond between them and their caregivers. This shared activity fosters trust, affection, and a sense of belonging, which are vital for a dog’s overall well-being and happiness. By understanding the significance of play and pack behavior, we can nurture the bond between ourselves and our canine companions.

Communication with Humans


Shaking toys can also be a means for dogs to communicate with their human companions. When a dog shakes a toy, they might be trying to catch your attention or signal that they want to engage in playtime with you. This behavior can be an effective way for them to express their needs and desires, as the movement and noise generated by the toy are hard to ignore.

Play Initiation

Dogs often use the act of shaking toys to initiate play with their human caregivers. By picking up a toy and shaking it in your presence, your dog is inviting you to join them in a fun and interactive game. Responding to this invitation not only strengthens the bond between you and your dog, but it also provides a healthy outlet for their energy and enthusiasm.

Affection Expression

Shaking toys can also be a way for dogs to express their affection towards their human companions. In some cases, a dog might shake a toy and then bring it to you as a gift, demonstrating their love and appreciation. By understanding the various ways in which dogs communicate with us through their actions, we can better meet their emotional needs and foster a strong, loving relationship.

Different Types of Toys and Shaking

Plush Toys

Plush toys are a favorite among dogs, as they resemble small prey animals in both size and texture. When a dog shakes a plush toy, they are likely tapping into their prey instincts, simulating the act of hunting, subduing, and killing prey. Plush toys with squeakers can be particularly enticing, as the noise produced mimics the sound of an injured animal.

Tug Toys

Tug toys, such as ropes or rubber rings, are designed for interactive play between dogs and their human companions. When a dog shakes a tug toy, they may be attempting to initiate a game of tug-of-war or showcasing their strength and skill. These toys provide an excellent opportunity for bonding and physical exercise.

Interactive Toys

Interactive toys, such as treat-dispensing balls or puzzle toys, engage a dog’s problem-solving abilities and provide mental stimulation. While dogs may not shake these toys as vigorously as plush or tug toys, they still enjoy manipulating them to access hidden treats or solve challenges. The act of shaking an interactive toy can help a dog figure out how to release the reward inside.

Chewing Toys

Chewing toys, like rubber bones or nylon chews, help to satisfy a dog’s natural urge to chew and promote dental health. Although dogs may not shake these toys as frequently as other types, they might still occasionally shake them to reposition them in their mouths or to express excitement. By offering a variety of toys, we can cater to our dogs’ diverse needs and instincts, ensuring their happiness and well-being.

Breed-Specific Tendencies


Terriers are known for their tenacious and energetic nature, which often translates to a strong prey drive. These breeds are more likely to vigorously shake their toys, as they were originally bred to hunt and kill vermin, such as rats and mice. Engaging in toy shaking allows terriers to fulfill their natural instincts in a controlled and safe environment.


Retrievers, such as Labrador Retrievers and Golden Retrievers, were bred to assist hunters by retrieving game, such as birds or small mammals. As a result, they may be more prone to shaking toys, mimicking the motion of capturing and retrieving prey. These breeds are also highly intelligent and enjoy engaging in interactive play with their human companions, making toy shaking a natural part of their playtime routine.

Herding Breeds

Herding breeds, such as Border Collies and Australian Shepherds, were developed to control the movement of livestock. Although their primary focus is on herding rather than hunting, they may still engage in toy shaking as a form of play and exercise. These intelligent and energetic dogs benefit from a variety of stimulating activities, including games that involve shaking and tugging toys.

Toy Breeds

Toy breeds, like Chihuahuas and Pomeranians, may be small in stature, but they still possess the same instincts as their larger counterparts. These breeds may shake their toys to mimic hunting behaviors, establish hierarchy, or simply engage in play with their human caregivers. Offering toy breeds appropriately sized toys can help to ensure they can safely and effectively engage in this instinctual behavior.

Age and Development Factors


During puppyhood, dogs are eager to explore their environment and learn new behaviors. Shaking toys can be an essential part of a puppy’s development, as it helps them practice their motor skills, build strength, and refine their instincts. Engaging in play with your puppy can help to build a strong bond and set the foundation for a healthy, happy adult dog.


As dogs mature, they continue to enjoy shaking toys and engaging in playtime. Adult dogs may shake toys to satisfy their prey drive, establish dominance, or simply as a form of exercise and stress relief. Regular playtime with a variety of toys can help to keep adult dogs physically fit, mentally stimulated, and emotionally balanced.

Senior Dogs

Senior dogs may experience a decline in energy levels and physical abilities, but they still benefit from engaging in play and toy shaking. Gentle, age-appropriate play can help to maintain a senior dog’s cognitive function, muscle tone, and overall well-being. Adapting playtime to accommodate an older dog’s changing needs can help to ensure they remain happy and healthy throughout their golden years.

Recognizing Problematic Shaking Behavior

Excessive Shaking

While shaking toys is a normal and healthy behavior for dogs, excessive shaking can indicate an underlying issue. If your dog is shaking toys constantly, to the point of ignoring other activities or becoming overly fixated, it may be a sign of boredom, stress, or anxiety. In such cases, it’s essential to address the root cause by providing additional mental and physical stimulation, as well as consulting with a veterinarian or professional dog trainer if necessary.


Shaking toys can sometimes escalate into aggressive behavior, especially if a dog becomes overly possessive of their toys or perceives a threat to their dominance. Signs of aggression can include growling, snapping, or lunging while shaking the toy. If your dog displays aggressive behavior during play, it’s crucial to address the issue promptly with the help of a professional dog trainer or behaviorist, who can recommend appropriate training techniques and interventions.

Destruction of Property

While some wear and tear on toys is expected during play, excessive destruction of property can be indicative of a problem. If your dog is not only shaking but also tearing apart toys, household items, or furniture, they may be experiencing frustration, boredom, or even separation anxiety. To address this issue, ensure your dog has access to durable, appropriate toys and engage them in regular exercise and mentally stimulating activities. If the destructive behavior persists, consult with a veterinarian or dog behaviorist for further guidance.

Addressing and Managing Toy Shaking

Positive Reinforcement

To encourage appropriate toy shaking behavior, use positive reinforcement techniques. Reward your dog with praise, treats, or affection when they engage in healthy play and shake their toys without displaying aggression or destructiveness. By consistently reinforcing positive behavior, you can help your dog associate toy shaking with a fun and rewarding experience.

Distraction Techniques

If your dog becomes overly fixated on shaking toys or starts to display problematic behavior, use distraction techniques to redirect their attention. Offer alternative activities, such as a game of fetch or a puzzle toy, to help your dog focus on something else. By providing a variety of engaging activities, you can help prevent excessive toy shaking and ensure your dog remains mentally and physically stimulated.

Training and Obedience

In some cases, addressing and managing toy shaking behavior may require additional training and obedience work. Teaching your dog basic commands, such as “leave it” or “drop it,” can help you maintain control during playtime and prevent aggressive or destructive behavior. If you’re unsure how to train your dog or need assistance with addressing problematic toy shaking, consult a professional dog trainer or behaviorist for guidance.

By understanding the reasons behind your dog’s toy shaking behavior and proactively addressing any issues, you can promote a healthy, happy, and well-balanced life for your beloved canine companion.


In conclusion, toy shaking is a natural and instinctual behavior for dogs that can be traced back to their evolutionary roots. By understanding the reasons behind this behavior, such as prey instinct, pack behavior, and communication with humans, we can better connect with our canine companions and promote a healthy, happy, and well-balanced life for them. Addressing and managing toy shaking through positive reinforcement, distraction techniques, and training can help ensure a safe and enjoyable playtime experience for both dogs and their human caregivers.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is toy shaking a sign of aggression?

Toy shaking in itself is not a sign of aggression; it’s a normal and instinctual behavior for dogs. However, if your dog displays aggressive behaviors, such as growling, snapping, or lunging while shaking a toy, it’s important to address the issue with the help of a professional dog trainer or behaviorist.

How can I prevent my dog from destroying toys?

To prevent your dog from destroying toys, provide them with durable, appropriately-sized toys designed for their specific breed and chewing strength. Regularly inspect toys for signs of wear and tear and replace them as needed. Engage your dog in a variety of mentally and physically stimulating activities to help prevent boredom and frustration that may lead to destructive behavior.

Are certain toys better for reducing shaking behavior?

There isn’t a specific type of toy that will reduce shaking behavior, as this is a natural and instinctual action for dogs. However, offering a variety of toys, including plush toys, tug toys, interactive toys, and chewing toys, can help provide your dog with diverse play experiences and prevent over-fixation on a single toy.

What if my dog doesn’t shake toys at all?

If your dog doesn’t shake toys at all, it’s not necessarily a cause for concern. Every dog is unique, and some may not be as inclined to engage in toy shaking behavior. As long as your dog is enjoying other forms of play and receiving adequate mental and physical stimulation, their well-being should not be negatively impacted.

How do I know if my dog’s toy shaking is a problem?

Your dog’s toy shaking may be a problem if it becomes excessive, aggressive, or destructive. Signs to watch for include constant toy shaking to the point of ignoring other activities, growling or snapping while shaking the toy, or damaging toys, household items, or furniture. If you notice any of these behaviors, consider consulting with a veterinarian, professional dog trainer, or behaviorist for guidance.