German Shepherd Pros and Cons for Potential Owners

by | German Shepherds, Dog Breeds

New Dog Tips is reader-supported. Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a small commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase a product or take an action via these links.

The German Shepherd, also known as the Alsatian in Britain and parts of Europe, is a working dog celebrated for its intelligence and versatility as a family pet, service animal, and working dog in various industries. Originating from Germany in the late 19th century, the German Shepherd was initially developed for herding sheep, owing to its intelligence, speed, and well-rounded temperament.

With their classic wolf-like appearance and striking demeanor, German Shepherds are instantly recognizable and adored by many for their loyalty, courage, and ability to be trained for various roles. Whether serving in police units, search and rescue operations, acting in movies, or simply being a dedicated family pet, German Shepherds have repeatedly proven that they are far more than just an ordinary breed. Read below to find out more about German Shepherd pros and cons.

The Popularity of German Shepherds

According to the American Kennel Club (AKC), German Shepherds have consistently ranked in the top five most popular breeds in the United States, a testament to their enduring appeal. They are cherished for their protective instincts, loyalty, and adaptability, making them a favorite choice among pet owners, families, and working professionals.

Indeed, the popularity of the German Shepherd extends well beyond the United States. This breed is highly regarded in many countries for its intelligence, trainability, and versatility. Despite the commitments and responsibilities of owning such a dynamic and active breed, many believe the benefits far outweigh the drawbacks, making the German Shepherd a beloved pet and a valued working partner worldwide.

The Pros of Owning a German Shepherd

Intelligence and Trainability

One of the most profound advantages of owning a German Shepherd is its intelligence and trainability. They are known to be among the most intelligent breeds, ranking third behind Border Collies and Poodles. This intellectual prowess is complemented by their keen desire to work, making them relatively easy to train.

German Shepherds are quick learners, able to pick up new commands and routines with fewer repetitions than many other breeds. This makes them particularly well-suited to obedience training, agility training, and more specialized forms of instruction, such as search and rescue or police work.

Versatility and Adaptability

German Shepherds are incredibly versatile and adaptable, traits that add to their appeal. They can thrive in various environments, whether in an apartment in a bustling city or a house with a large backyard in the countryside. However, regardless of the living situation, providing them with ample exercise and mental stimulation is crucial to keep them healthy and content.

Their adaptability also extends to their capacity to fill a variety of roles. German Shepherds can transition seamlessly from a family pet to a working dog, demonstrating their versatility and remarkable ability to adjust to different situations and environments.

Loyalty and Protective Nature

German Shepherds are renowned for their loyalty and protective nature. They are naturally protective of their “pack” and can be wary of strangers, making them excellent guard dogs. This breed forms strong bonds with their family and often exhibits a keen instinct to safeguard their loved ones.

While this protective instinct is a boon for those seeking a guard dog, it’s important to socialize German Shepherds from a young age to ensure they can distinguish between everyday situations and actual threats. Despite their watchful nature, they are typically very gentle and affectionate with their families, further solidifying their place as a preferred breed for many households.

Excellent Working Abilities

German Shepherds have excellent working abilities, a trait deeply ingrained in their heritage. Initially bred for herding, these dogs are built for work. Their intelligence, physical prowess, and eager-to-please attitude make them excellent working dogs in various fields, including police work, search and rescue, and service animals.

Potential as a Service or Working Dog

Thanks to their intelligence, trainability, and adaptability, German Shepherds are often the breed of choice for many service roles. They are commonly used as guide dogs for the visually impaired, in police and military roles, for search and rescue, and even in therapeutic settings as emotional support animals.

Their intuitive nature makes them particularly adept at tasks that require sensitivity to human emotions and needs. As a result, they’re frequently trained as psychiatric service dogs, providing critical support for individuals with mental health conditions such as PTSD, anxiety, and depression.

The Cons of Owning a German Shepherd

High Exercise and Mental Stimulation Needs

While German Shepherds’ high energy levels and intelligence are beneficial in many ways, they also mean that this breed requires significant exercise and mental stimulation. Inadequate physical activity or mental engagement can lead to behavioral issues such as destructive behavior, excessive barking, and hyperactivity.

Owners must be ready to commit to daily walks, playtimes, and cognitive enrichment, such as puzzle toys or obedience training, to keep a German Shepherd happy and well-behaved. This demand for exercise and mental stimulation makes German Shepherds less suitable for individuals or families with a sedentary lifestyle.

Potential for Behavioral Issues

German Shepherds, like all breeds, can develop behavioral issues if not properly trained and socialized from a young age. Their protective nature can lead to aggressive tendencies if not managed correctly. Furthermore, without sufficient stimulation, they can exhibit symptoms of anxiety and boredom, which may manifest as destructive behavior.

Therefore, investing time in training and socializing a German Shepherd is crucial. This includes exposing them to various people, places, and experiences to foster their confidence and ensure their comfort in different situations.

Grooming and Shedding Requirements

German Shepherds are known for their thick double coats, which protect them from harsh weather conditions but also result in significant shedding. They are sometimes jokingly called “German Shedders” due to how much hair they can leave around your home.

Regular grooming is necessary to manage shedding and maintain the health of their coat. This includes daily brushing during peak shedding seasons. While this doesn’t necessarily pose a problem, it can be a considerable commitment for some owners and a point to consider for those with allergies.

Size and Space Considerations

German Shepherds are large dogs, typically weighing between 50 and 90 pounds. Their size and high energy levels mean they’ll do best with plenty of space to run and play. While they can adapt to living in an apartment, it will require extra effort to meet their exercise needs without a large yard.

Furthermore, their size means they’ll require more food and can be more expensive to care for than smaller breeds. From larger beds to higher doses of medication, larger dogs generally require a larger investment.

Health Issues and Potential Medical Expenses

German Shepherds are prone to certain genetic health issues like many purebred dogs. These can include hip and elbow dysplasia, degenerative myelopathy, and certain heart conditions. Owning a German Shepherd may involve higher medical expenses, particularly as they age and if these conditions manifest.

Regular check-ups and preventative care can help catch and manage many of these issues early. However, potential German Shepherd owners should be aware of these health concerns and be financially prepared for possible medical costs.

German Shepherds as Family Pets

German Shepherds and Children

German Shepherds are known to be very good with children when properly socialized and trained. They often protect the children in their family, treating them as members of their pack. Their intelligence and playful nature can make them excellent playmates for older children. However, due to their size, interactions with small children should always be supervised to prevent accidental injuries.

Compatibility with Other Pets

With early socialization, German Shepherds can get along well with other pets, including dogs and cats. They are, however, a dominant breed and may do best with pets of the opposite sex. Introducing a German Shepherd to other pets should be done carefully and gradually to establish a positive relationship.

Socialization and Training Importance

Socialization and training are key to raising a well-adjusted German Shepherd. Exposure to various people, environments, sounds, and experiences early in life will help them grow confident and relaxed in different situations. Regular training sessions teach necessary obedience commands and provide mental stimulation for this intelligent breed.

German Shepherds as Guard Dogs

Natural Protective Instincts

German Shepherds are well-known for their natural protective instincts. They are always alert and watchful, making them excellent guard dogs for homes and properties. They are naturally suspicious of strangers and will not hesitate to protect their families if they perceive a threat. However, this protective nature should be managed with careful training to prevent unnecessary aggression or fearfulness.

Training for Guard Duties

While German Shepherds have a natural propensity towards protective behavior, proper training is still crucial if they are to be used as guard dogs. This includes obedience training, socialization, and, potentially, specialized guard dog training. A well-trained German Shepherd guard dog should be able to differentiate between normal and suspicious behavior and react accordingly.

Liability and Legal Considerations

While having a German Shepherd as a guard dog has advantages, it also comes with certain liabilities and legal considerations. Owners could be held liable if their dog injures someone, even if the dog was acting in a perceived protective capacity. Depending on local laws, additional legal requirements for owning a guard dog may exist, such as specific insurance coverage. Therefore, it’s essential to understand and adhere to local laws and regulations when employing a German Shepherd as a guard dog.

German Shepherds in Different Environments

Urban Living and Apartment Dwellers

Despite their large size and high energy levels, German Shepherds can adapt to urban living, including apartment dwellings, provided they receive adequate exercise and mental stimulation. Daily walks, playtime, and regular dog park trips can help keep an apartment-dwelling German Shepherd healthy and content.

However, potential owners should be aware of their local building’s pet policies, as some places may restrict larger breeds. Noise may also be a concern, as German Shepherds can be vocal, especially if bored or anxious.

Rural Settings and Active Lifestyles

German Shepherds thrive in rural settings and are well-suited to active lifestyles. With plenty of space to run and play, these dogs can enjoy the physical activity they need to stay healthy. A German Shepherd can make an excellent companion for active individuals or families who enjoy outdoor activities like hiking, running, or camping.

Moreover, their intelligence and work ethic make them well-suited to roles on farms and in rural settings, such as herding livestock or acting as general farm dog. They are versatile dogs that can adjust well to the demands of rural living.

Climate Considerations

German Shepherds have a double coat that provides insulation both in cold and warm conditions. They can tolerate a range of climates, but care should be taken in extreme conditions. In hot weather, it’s important to ensure they have access to shade and fresh water, and exercise should be limited during the hottest parts of the day.

Even though they are quite resistant in cold weather, German Shepherds should have a warm shelter to protect them from freezing temperatures. Despite their adaptability, potential owners should consider their local climate and make suitable accommodations for their German Shepherd to ensure their comfort and health.

Responsible Ownership and Care

Time Commitment and Attention

German Shepherds require a significant time commitment from their owners. They are not a breed that can be left alone for long periods regularly, as they thrive on human interaction and can develop separation anxiety if left alone too much. From training to exercise and play, these dogs need regular and meaningful interaction with their family.

Exercise and Mental Stimulation Requirements

Exercise and mental stimulation are non-negotiable requirements for German Shepherds. Daily walks, playtime, and mental challenges are necessary to keep this intelligent and active breed content. Inadequate exercise or mental stimulation can lead to behavioral problems, including destructiveness and excessive barking. It’s important to remember that a tired German Shepherd is a happy and well-behaved German Shepherd.

Proper Nutrition and Health Care

German Shepherds require a balanced and nutritious diet to support their active lifestyle and health. This usually includes high-quality commercial dog food or well-planned homemade meals complemented by appropriate treats. Regular veterinary check-ups and vaccinations are essential to monitoring their health, and preventative care such as flea, tick, and worming treatments should not be neglected.

As mentioned previously, German Shepherds are susceptible to certain genetic health issues. Therefore, regular health screenings and staying alert to any changes in their behavior or condition are essential aspects of responsible German Shepherd ownership.

Grooming and Coat Maintenance

Regular grooming is an essential part of caring for a German Shepherd. These dogs have a dense double coat that sheds heavily, especially during the shedding seasons in spring and fall. Daily brushing during these times will help to manage shedding and keep their coat healthy. Additionally, regular baths, nail trims, and teeth cleanings are all part of the essential care routine for this breed.

While owning a German Shepherd is a significant commitment, they can make a wonderful and rewarding addition to a suitable home with the correct care, attention, and training.

Final Thoughts: Weighing the German Shepherd Pros and Cons

German Shepherds are intelligent, versatile, and loyal dogs that can bring great joy to their owners. They are adaptable and thrive in various environments with active lifestyles. Their trainability and protective nature make them excellent working or guard dogs, and their love for their families makes them delightful companions.

However, they come with challenges, including a high need for exercise and mental stimulation, grooming requirements, and potential health issues. Their size and energy make them less suitable for apartment living or sedentary lifestyles.

Before deciding to adopt or buy a German Shepherd, potential owners should consider their lifestyle, living situation, and ability to meet the breed’s needs. Understanding the commitment required in terms of time and resources is crucial. Potential owners should also consider seeking a reputable breeder or considering adoption from a rescue group dedicated to German Shepherds.


Are German Shepherds good with children?

Yes, German Shepherds are generally good with children, especially when raised together. However, due to their size and energy, interactions with small children should always be supervised.

How much exercise do German Shepherds need?

German Shepherds require significant exercise—usually at least 1-2 hours daily. This should include a mix of walks, playtime, and mental stimulation activities.

Do German Shepherds require special grooming?

German Shepherds have a double coat that sheds heavily, especially during the shedding seasons. Regular brushing is necessary to manage shedding, and additional grooming tasks include regular baths, nail trims, and teeth cleanings.

Are German Shepherds prone to specific health issues?

German Shepherds are prone to certain genetic health issues, including hip and elbow dysplasia, degenerative myelopathy, and heart conditions. Regular health screenings and veterinary care are important to maintain their health.

Can German Shepherds be left alone for long periods?

German Shepherds thrive on interaction and activity, so they should not be left alone for long periods. They can develop separation anxiety or destructive behaviors if left alone regularly or for extended periods.