Find the Perfect Toy for Your Pup: A Guide to Dog Toys

by | Products

New Dog Tips is reader-supported. Some links may be affiliate links. We may earn a small commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase a product or take an action via these links.

Play is essential to a dog’s life, contributing to their overall health and happiness. Engaging your canine companion in regular playtime helps strengthen the bond between you and your pet and provides valuable mental and physical stimulation. A well-chosen dog toy can greatly enhance your pup’s playtime experience, but finding the perfect toy for your furry friend can be challenging with so many options on the market. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore the importance of play for dogs, the benefits of appropriate dog toys, and provide an overview of choosing the best toy for your canine companion.

The Importance of Play for Dogs

Play is crucial for dogs as it helps them develop essential skills and maintain their physical and mental well-being. Through play, dogs learn how to socialize with other animals, practice hunting and problem-solving skills, and release pent-up energy. Additionally, playtime allows dogs to build strong connections with their human companions, fostering trust and loyalty.

Benefits of Appropriate Dog Toys

Investing in the right dog toys has numerous benefits for you and your canine companion. Some of the key benefits include:

  • Physical exercise: Dog toys can encourage physical activity, helping to keep your pet fit and active and maintain a healthy weight.
  • Mental stimulation: Interactive toys, such as puzzle toys, can help to challenge your dog’s mind and alleviate boredom, reducing the risk of destructive behaviors.
  • Stress relief: Chewing on toys can help dogs relieve stress and anxiety, promoting a sense of calm and relaxation.
  • Dental health: Some dog toys are designed to help clean teeth and massage gums, promoting good oral hygiene.
  • Training aid: Toys can be used as a reward during training sessions, reinforcing positive behaviors and strengthening the bond between you and your pet.

In the following sections of this guide, we’ll delve deeper into the various factors to consider when selecting the perfect toy for your canine companion. We’ll discuss different types of toys, their specific purposes, and how to match a toy to your dog’s size, breed, and play preferences. By the end of this guide, you’ll be well-equipped to make an informed decision and provide your furry friend with a toy they will love and enjoy for hours.

small black Basenji puppy bites pillow. Concept for when do puppies get easier to manage

Understanding Your Dog’s Play Style

Observing Your Dog at Play

Before choosing a toy for your canine companion, it’s essential to understand their play style. To do this, spend some time observing your dog at play. Take note of their favorite activities, whether they prefer playing alone or with other dogs, and if they are more interested in fetching, tugging, or chewing. Also, pay attention to specific behaviors, such as digging or chasing, that your dog enjoys.

Identifying Play Preferences

Once you’ve observed your dog at play, you should be able to identify their play preferences. Some common play styles include:

  • Fetchers: Dogs who love to chase after and retrieve objects.
  • Tuggers: Dogs who enjoy tug-of-war games with their owners or other dogs.
  • Chewers: Dogs who enjoy gnawing on toys or other objects for extended periods.
  • Puzzle solvers: Dogs who are captivated by mental challenges and enjoy problem-solving toys.
  • Comfort seekers: Dogs who prefer soft, cuddly toys for companionship and snuggling.

Remember that many dogs have a combination of play preferences, so it’s important to provide them with various toys to accommodate their diverse interests.

Matching Toys to Play Styles

With your dog’s play preferences in mind, you can select toys that align with their unique play style. Here are some suggestions for matching toys to play styles:

  • Fetchers: Opt for balls, flying discs, or durable fetch sticks that withstand repeated throwing and retrieving.
  • Tuggers: Choose rope toys, durable rubber tug toys, or toys with handles that allow for a good grip during tug-of-war games.
  • Chewers: Look for durable, long-lasting chew toys from rubber, nylon, or natural fibers.
  • Puzzle solvers: Select interactive puzzle or treat-dispensing toys that challenge your dog’s mind and reward them for their efforts.
  • Comfort seekers: Provide plush or soft, fleece-covered toys for snuggling and companionship.

Choosing toys that cater to your dog’s play style will create a more enjoyable and engaging playtime experience for your furry friend. Visit Chewy to find a wide range of toys for your best friend.

Toy Categories and Key Features

Chew Toys

Classic Chew Toys

Classic chew toys are designed to withstand vigorous gnawing and are typically made from durable materials like rubber or nylon. These toys are ideal for dogs who love to chew and can help redirect their energy away from destructive behaviors like chewing on furniture.

Dental Chew Toys

Dental chew toys are specially designed to promote good oral hygiene. These toys often feature textured surfaces that help to clean teeth and massage gums as your dog chews, reducing plaque and tartar buildup. Dental chew toys may come in various shapes and flavors to entertain your dog.

Interactive Chew Toys

Interactive chew toys combine the benefits of classic chew toys with an additional element of mental stimulation. These toys may include compartments for hiding treats, squeakers, or other engaging features that encourage your dog to chew and interact with the toy for longer.

Fetch and Tug Toys


Balls are a staple in many dog toy collections and come in various sizes, materials, and designs. Some balls are made from durable rubber or nylon, while others may be softer and made from fleece or plush material. Look for balls appropriately sized for your dog’s mouth and designed for their specific play style. See on Chewy.


Frisbees are popular for dogs who love chasing and catching objects mid-air. Opt for dog-friendly frisbees made from soft, flexible materials that won’t hurt your dog’s mouth when caught. These toys are excellent for outdoor play and can provide hours of entertainment for you and your dog.

Tug-of-War Toys

Tug-of-war toys, such as rope toys or toys with handles, are designed for interactive play between you and your dog or between multiple dogs. These toys encourage physical activity and can help strengthen the bond between you and your canine companion. Choose tug toys made from durable materials that withstand repeated tugging and pulling.

Puzzle and Treat-Dispensing Toys

Puzzle Toys

Puzzle toys challenge your dog’s problem-solving skills and provide mental stimulation. These toys often feature hidden compartments and moving parts or require specific actions for your dog to access treats or other rewards. Puzzle toys can help alleviate boredom and reduce the risk of destructive behaviors in dogs that crave mental engagement.

Treat-Dispensing Toys

Treat-dispensing toys are designed to hold and release treats or kibble as your dog interacts with the toy. These toys can help slow your dog’s eating, provide mental stimulation, and keep them entertained for extended periods. Treat-dispensing toys come in various sizes, shapes, and difficulty levels to suit your dog’s size and skill level.

Plush and Comfort Toys

Stuffed Animals

Stuffed animals provide soft, cuddly companionship for dogs who enjoy snuggling or gently mouthing their toys. Look for stuffed animals made from durable materials with reinforced seams, and avoid toys with small parts or plastic eyes that could pose a choking hazard. Remember that some dogs may be more prone to destroying stuffed animals, so monitor your dog’s play to ensure their safety.

Snuggle Blankets

Snuggle blankets are soft, plush blankets explicitly designed for dogs who seek comfort and companionship from their toys. These blankets can provide security and help reduce anxiety in some dogs, especially during separation or stress. Choose a snuggle blanket made from durable, machine-washable materials to ensure easy cleaning and long-lasting use.

Calming Toys

Calming toys are designed to help soothe and comfort anxious or stressed dogs. These toys may incorporate a lavender scent, gentle vibrations, or a simulated heartbeat to provide a sense of calm and relaxation. Calming toys can be beneficial during potentially stressful situations, such as thunderstorms, fireworks, or trips to the vet.

Young beautiul golden retriever dog playing with rubber puppy toys. Isolated over white background.

Safety Considerations

Selecting the Right Size

Choosing the appropriate size toy for your dog is crucial for their safety and enjoyment. A toy that is too small can pose a choking hazard, while a toy that is too large may be challenging for your dog to handle and play with comfortably. Consider your dog’s size, breed, and mouth shape when selecting a toy. Always opt for toys designed for your dog’s size to minimize risks and maximize playtime enjoyment.

Material Safety

The materials used in dog toys should be non-toxic and safe for your pet to chew and play with. Look for toys made from high-quality, pet-safe materials such as natural rubber, non-toxic plastics, or eco-friendly fabrics. Avoid toys with a strong chemical smell, which can indicate potentially harmful substances. If you’re unsure about the safety of a particular toy, consult with your veterinarian or a pet product expert for guidance.

Supervision During Play

While providing your dog with plenty of opportunities for independent play is essential, supervising their playtime is equally important to ensure their safety. Keep a close eye on your dog as they interact with their toys, especially when introducing a new toy or playing with other dogs. This will allow you to intervene quickly if a toy becomes damaged or poses a safety risk to your pet.

Regular Toy Inspections and Replacements

Regularly inspect your dog’s toys for signs of wear and tear, such as frayed edges, torn seams, or missing parts. Damaged toys can pose a choking hazard or lead to injury if ingested. Replace worn-out or damaged toys promptly to ensure your dog’s continued safety and enjoyment. Establishing a routine for toy inspections and replacements can help maintain a safe and engaging play environment for your canine companion.

Popular and Trusted Toy Brands


Kong is a well-known and trusted brand in the pet industry, offering a wide range of high-quality dog toys designed for durability and safe play. Their iconic Kong Classic toy, made from natural rubber, is a favorite among dog owners for its versatility and ability to withstand vigorous chewing. Kong also offers a variety of other toys, including plush toys, treat-dispensing toys, and fetch toys, catering to the diverse play preferences of dogs of all sizes and breeds.


Chuckit! is best known for its innovative fetch toys that aim to elevate the game of fetch for both dogs and their human companions. Their popular ball launcher allows pet owners to throw balls farther and with less effort, providing dogs with a more engaging and stimulating fetch experience. Chuckit! also offers a variety of other fetch toys, such as flying discs and durable rubber balls, all designed with the active, outdoor-loving dog in mind.

West Paw

West Paw is committed to creating safe, durable, eco-friendly dog toys. Their Zogoflex line of toys, made from a proprietary blend of non-toxic, recyclable materials, is known for its exceptional durability and resistance to chewing. West Paw offers a range of toy options, including chew toys, fetch toys, and treat-dispensing toys, all backed by a satisfaction guarantee, ensuring that you and your dog will be happy with your purchase.


Tuffy specializes in creating durable plush toys that withstand rough play and vigorous chewing. Their toys feature multiple layers of materials, reinforced seams, and protective webbing, making them more damage-resistant than traditional plush toys. Tuffy offers a wide selection of toy designs and sizes, catering to dogs of all breeds and play styles, and includes a toughness rating on each toy to help pet owners select the most appropriate option for their dogs.

Outward Hound

Outward Hound is a brand that offers a diverse selection of dog toys focusing on interactive play and mental stimulation. Their popular line of puzzle toys is designed to challenge your dog’s problem-solving skills and provide enrichment during playtime. Outward Hound also offers a variety of other toy options, including plush toys, chew toys, and fetch toys, ensuring that there’s something to suit the preferences of every canine companion.

Customizing Toys for Your Dog

DIY Toy Ideas

Creating your DIY dog toys can be a fun and cost-effective way to provide your dog with unique and personalized play options. Some popular DIY toy ideas include:

  • T-shirt tug toy: Repurpose old t-shirts by cutting them into strips and braiding them together to create a durable, eco-friendly tug toy.
  • Tennis ball treat dispenser: Make a simple treat-dispensing toy by cutting a small slit in a tennis ball and filling it with your dog’s favorite treats or kibble.
  • Cardboard puzzle box: Use a cardboard box, paper towel rolls, and treats to create a homemade puzzle toy that challenges your dog’s problem-solving skills.

When creating DIY toys, always prioritize your dog’s safety by using pet-safe materials and avoiding small parts that could pose a choking hazard.

Personalizing Store-Bought Toys

You can add a personal touch to store-bought toys by incorporating your dog’s favorite scents, flavors, or textures. For example:

  • Flavored toys: Rub a store-bought toy with your dog’s favorite treats or food to make it more appealing and enticing.
  • Interactive play: Combine multiple toys to create unique play experiences, such as attaching a treat-dispensing toy to a rope for an engaging game of tug-of-war.
  • Customized comfort: Add your scent to a plush toy or snuggle blanket by sleeping with it for a few nights before giving it to your dog, providing them with a comforting reminder of your presence.

Get creative with personalizing your dog’s toys, but always keep safety in mind and ensure that any modifications are appropriate for your dog’s size and play preferences.

Toy Rotation and Variety

Maintaining a variety of toys and rotating them regularly can help keep your dog’s interest and prevent boredom. Toy rotation can also extend the life of your dog’s toys, as they won’t be subjected to constant wear and tear. To implement a toy rotation:

  1. Select a variety of toys that cater to your dog’s play preferences and stimulate different senses, such as chew toys, fetch toys, puzzle toys, and comfort toys.
  2. Introduce a few toys at a time, allowing your dog to play with them for a week or two before swapping them out for a new selection.
  3. Regularly inspect and clean the toys in rotation, replacing any worn-out or damaged items.

By customizing toys and providing a diverse selection, you can create a more engaging and enjoyable play environment for your canine companion.

Puppy chewing on rope toy

Toys for Specific Dog Needs


Teething Toys

Puppies undergo a teething phase, exploring the world by mouthing and chewing on objects. Providing them with safe and appropriate teething toys can help soothe their gums, alleviate discomfort, and redirect their chewing instincts. Look for toys made from soft yet durable materials like rubber or silicone, designed specifically for teething puppies.

Early Training Toys

Early training toys can help puppies develop essential skills, such as problem-solving, coordination, and socialization. Consider introducing puzzle, treat-dispensing, or interactive toys that encourage positive play behaviors and help establish a strong foundation for future training.

Senior Dogs

Gentle Chew Toys

Senior dogs may still enjoy chewing but require softer and gentler toys due to dental or gum issues. Opt for chew toys made from pliable materials or plush toys that provide a satisfying chewing experience without causing discomfort or damage to their teeth and gums.

Cognitive Stimulation Toys

As dogs age, maintaining their cognitive health becomes increasingly important. Puzzle toys, treat-dispensing toys, or toys that incorporate scent can help keep their minds sharp and engaged, potentially slowing down the progression of age-related cognitive decline.

Dogs with Special Needs

Toys for Visually Impaired Dogs

Dogs with visual impairments can still enjoy playtime with toys stimulate their other senses. Consider toys that make noise, such as squeaky toys or toys with bells, or toys with unique textures that are easy for your dog to locate and interact with through touch.

Toys for Dogs with Limited Mobility

Dogs with limited mobility may not be able to engage in vigorous play but can still benefit from toys that provide mental stimulation and gentle physical activity. Treat-dispensing puzzles, or toys that can be easily manipulated without excessive movement, can offer an enjoyable play experience for dogs with mobility challenges.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the perfect toy for your canine companion is crucial to maintaining their happiness, mental and physical health, and overall well-being. By understanding your dog’s play preferences, selecting toys from trusted brands, considering safety factors, and accommodating specific needs, you can create an engaging and enjoyable play environment for your furry friend. Remember to regularly assess and update your dog’s toy collection to ensure that they stay interested and stimulated throughout their lives.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How often should I replace my dog’s toys?

The frequency with which you should replace your dog’s toys depends on factors such as the toy’s durability, play habits, and overall condition. Regularly inspect your dog’s toys for signs of wear and tear, and promptly replace any damaged or worn-out toys to ensure their safety and enjoyment.

Can I use household items as dog toys?

While some household items can be repurposed as DIY dog toys, it’s essential to prioritize your dog’s safety by using pet-safe materials and avoiding small parts that could pose a choking hazard. Always supervise your dog when they’re playing with homemade toys and replace any items that become damaged or worn out.

How do I clean and sanitize dog toys?

The cleaning method for dog toys depends on the toy’s material and construction. For rubber, plastic, and silicone toys, you can wash them with warm water and mild dish soap, then rinse thoroughly and allow them to air dry. Plush toys can often be machine-washed on a gentle cycle and air-dried. Always follow the manufacturer’s cleaning instructions and avoid using harsh chemicals that could harm your pet.

Are there any toys I should avoid for my dog’s breed?

Some dog breeds may be predisposed to certain health issues or have unique play habits that should be considered when selecting toys. For example, brachycephalic breeds, such as Pugs or Bulldogs, may struggle with certain chew toys due to their facial structure. Researching your dog’s breed and consulting with your veterinarian or a pet expert to determine which toys suit your dog’s specific needs is essential.

What if my dog shows no interest in a new toy?

If your dog shows no interest in a new toy, you can try to make it more appealing by adding your dog’s favorite scents, flavors, or textures. Engage in interactive play with the toy or introduce it alongside other favorite toys to create a positive association. If your dog still shows no interest, consider trying a different type of toy that better aligns with their play preferences or consult with a pet expert for recommendations.